Growing Early access

Blog

Can you spoil a newborn?

It’s three in the morning, he only settles on your chest, and someone has told you that you’re making a rod for your own back. The short answer is no. The longer answer has one important part about sleep.

General information, not medical advice. Talk to your child’s doctor about your child. If you’re worried about your child’s health right now, call your pediatrician or your local emergency number.

The answer

The American Academy of Pediatrics says it directly: you cannot spoil a young baby with attention. Its guidance for the first few months is to respond promptly when your baby cries, and it adds that babies whose calls are answered cry less overall.

A newborn has very few ways to tell you anything, and crying is the main one. The AAP describes cries as calls for help, and its advice is to answer them.

The milestone lists point the same way. On the CDC’s two-month checklist, one of the things most babies do is calm down when spoken to or picked up. Being soothed by you is the skill at this age. It is on the list of things going right.

How much crying is ordinary

More than most people expect. The AAP says newborns routinely cry one to four hours a day. It also says the cries start to vary as the weeks go by, as if to convey different needs, and that a young baby’s difficulty in settling themselves improves as they mature.

Among the things the AAP suggests trying are rocking, in a chair or in your arms as you sway from side to side, and safe swaddling.

When you can’t make it stop

Some crying will not respond to anything you do, and that says nothing about how well you are doing. The AAP’s advice for that moment is practical:

  • If you have tried to soothe your baby and the crying goes on, set the baby down in a safe place and get help from a family member or friend. A new face sometimes calms a baby, and you get a break.
  • However impatient or angry you feel, never shake or hit a baby. Shaking an infant hard can cause blindness, brain damage or death.
  • A baby who is inconsolable may be sick. Check their temperature. A rectal temperature of 100.4°F (38°C) or higher could mean an infection, and the AAP says to contact your pediatrician.

Putting a crying baby down safely for a few minutes so you can breathe is one of the things the guidance tells you to do.

Sleep in the first months

The AAP says newborns sleep about 16 to 17 hours a day, but often only one or two hours at a time, and that babies do not have regular sleep cycles until about four months of age. A six-week-old who wakes every hour or two is doing what the AAP describes for a newborn.

The same AAP page does suggest habits that can make nights easier over time: keep nights calm and quiet, make daytime the time for play, and put your baby down drowsy and not yet asleep. It notes that babies who are always held or rocked to sleep may find it harder to go back to sleep on their own when they wake. That is advice about how falling asleep is learned over months. It does not mean that comforting a newborn does harm.

The part that matters most: where sleep happens

“He only sleeps when I’m holding him” is a safety question before it is a habits question, because a tired adult holding a sleeping baby can fall asleep too. The AAP’s safe sleep guidance is specific:

  • Place your baby on their back for every sleep, naps and nights.
  • Use a firm, flat sleep surface, with soft objects and loose bedding kept out of it.
  • Share a room, not a bed, for at least the first six months.
  • If your baby falls asleep in a car seat, swing or carrier, move them to a firm sleep surface on their back as soon as you can.
  • Falling asleep with a baby on a couch is especially dangerous. The AAP puts the risk of sleep-related death at up to 67 times higher when a baby sleeps with someone on a couch.
  • If you think you might fall asleep, put your baby back in their own sleep space first.

So hold him as much as you like while you are awake. When you feel yourself going, put him down on his back in his own space or hand him to another adult, even if he complains about it.

When to bring it up

The AAP’s guidance is to check the temperature of a baby who can’t be consoled, and to contact your pediatrician if it is 100.4°F (38°C) or higher. If the crying worries you for any other reason, calling is a reasonable thing to do. Bring it up at the next visit if the crying or the nights are wearing you down. How you are coping is a fair thing to raise at a baby’s check-up.

To ask at the next visit

“He only settles when he’s held, and I’m afraid of falling asleep with him. What can we try, and what’s safe?”

For what else is typical at two months and after, see Milestones by age.

Sources

  1. American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org, Responding To Your Baby’s Cries.
  2. American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org, Getting Your Baby to Sleep.
  3. American Academy of Pediatrics, HealthyChildren.org, How to Keep Your Sleeping Baby Safe: AAP Policy Explained.
  4. CDC, Learn the Signs. Act Early., Milestones by 2 Months.